…I can imagine, though, that in a later stage of this interesting research, additional studies may substantiate the authors’ major point, illustrating that the Hermitian Form Model is not only an elegant tool but can also improve our understanding of the cognitive processes and constraints involved in the memorization of triadic and more complex structures. Towards that end, it would be important to explain and validate specific assumptions about what eigenvector features indicate what cognitive operation, or constraint. And it would be necessary to let the present conception compete with other, traditional approaches to balanced structures. Nevertheless, although I cannot vote for publication in this case, I must confess that I feel that I have been exposed to a very interesting idea.
またリジェクトなんですけどね、コメントに感心させられました。
内容の理解はしているし、将来性はあるだろうけど、現状(本稿）は不採用です、という。断るにしても色々言葉を尽くして、encourageしてくれているので、なんだかそれほど悪い気はしない。こういう、論文コメントのマナーが美しいなぁと思うし、自分もこういう物言いで表現できるようにならないとな、と思うような次第。そのためにも、もっともっとリジェクトをくらわないと駄目ですな（笑）